IrishItalian Provide legal advice or act as your legal representative in or out of court. Removing a licensee from serving in his or her duly appointed capacity or appointing a licensee as conservator, trustee, guardian, agent under a durable power of attorney, or personal representative of a decedents estate. It's the right way to do business. BelarusianBulgarian To file a complaint either call (520) 724-7400 and ask to speak to a Complaint Coordinator, or fill out our web based Complaint Form if you wish to remain anonymous. Laurie Kuzdal, licensed private fiduciary, is the owner of Arizona Fiduciary Services, llc. These simple steps can help you attain peace-of-mind regarding complex decisions and emotions. Pursuant to BPC section 6581, a licensee, or an agent working on behalf of a licensee, including an attorney, is not permitted to bill a client or impose a fee on the estate or trust of a client for responding to a complaint filed with the Bureau against the licensee. We investigate complaints involving deceptive or unfair practices which occur in connection with the sale or advertisement of goods or services. NGF certifications must be renewed every two years. General Inquiries Call: (602) 452-3378 Does a manager of an Arizona LLC owe fiduciary . The fiduciary will investigate the situation and, if there appears to be a demonstrated need and there is no other alternative, the fiduciary will retain an attorney to petition the probate court for appointment as guardian or conservator. Educator Links Laurie is a Certified Paralegal for the State of Arizona, a Certified Fraud Examiner, a Certified Elder Mediator and a, Discover What a Private Fiduciary Can Do for You, As a licensed, bonded, and fingerprinted professional Arizona fiduciary, we can serve as your, Whether you are a named Trustee or setting up your own trust, our professional private fiduciary can manage, If you are the named trustee for an Arizona estate but reside outside of Arizona, we can help you maneuver through Arizona estate law. Provide your complaint to your financial institution or enterprise and require them to respond to us. The guidelines listed below are general steps after a complaint has been filed with the Certifications and Licensing Division (Division). Our mission is to be recognized as one of Arizona's top-rated fiduciary firms. The public fiduciary is considered the "fiduciary of last resort" when there is no one else willing or capable of serving. Arizona Fiduciary Services (520) 820-4757. A will typically names a personal representative. 1) Look up the pertinent license information for whom you wish to file a complaint on. A private fiduciary in Arizona is someone appointed by the court to handle the health care or finances of another non-family member person. If the location you are looking for is not listed, visit the public access to court information page provided by the Arizona Judicial Branch. A professional fiduciary will charge fees based on an hourly rate and time expended whereas a corporate trustee will charge basis points or a percentage fee based on the market value of the estate. Your first consultation is absolutely free, whether by phone, video or in person. The Arizona Attorney General is required by state law to keep a registry of names of persons against whom complaints have been filed accusing them of abuse, neglect or exploitation of a vulnerable person. A trust is a legal entity created by one or more persons called trustors, who appoint a trustee to manage the trusts assets according to the terms of the trust. Volunteer-AmeriCorps, Helpful Links State Bar of Arizona CORP Website Staff Login, Translate this Page: CzechDanish Latin ALPHALatvian ThaiTurkish The DIFI also investigates complaints filed against individuals or companies suspected of engaging in unlicensed activities. I will be forever grateful for your kindness. In that case, however, the Bureau may not be able to contact you or help resolve your complaint. Legal Reference & Links EstonianFilipino Trustors usually name themselves as the primary beneficiaries during their lifetime. Commission on Judicial Conduct These fiduciary duties typically include the obligations of loyalty, good faith, and to act with a certain degree of care in handling company matters. EstonianFilipino We can also make referrals to competent professional specialists. Justice Court Record Requests. Azerbaijani ALPHABasque ALPHA Persons serving as fiduciaries for a fee must be licensed by the State of Arizona. Weaddress each persons needson an individualized basis and work to create a caring and respectful relationship with our clients and their families. Contact Us. Yiddish You are not required to provide personal information in order to file a complaint. If you have questions concerning your personal legal rights or responsibilities, you should contact a private attorney. GermanGreek You can submit more evidence for a Veterans Law Judge to review. In Arizona there are public fiduciaries and licensed fiduciaries in private practice. By continuing to the Financial Institution or Enterprise complaint form, you ACKNOWLEDGE the following: The DIFIs ability to take action with respect to a particular complaint is limited to situations where there is an apparent violation of those statutes and rules subject to its jurisdiction. Once the petition for appointment is filed with the probate court, the court appoints an attorney to represent the alleged incapacitated person. and its regulations, or of any of the statutes, rules, or regulations pertaining to duties or functions of a professional fiduciary. A private fiduciary can help to protect you, your assets and your loved ones in a variety of ways. . They also serve by agreement as trustees, representative payees for Social Security income or other income benefit plans, or as agents under powers of attorney. Many trustees fail to meet the requirements of the law with an annual accounting report. Attorneys in Arizona and throughout the U.S. call on us for timesaving paralegal assistance to their local clients. Adult residents of Arizona can become licensed if they they meet requirements laid out by the Arizona Supreme Court. Disclose complaint information to the public. [emailprotected] Your Service TFO Phoenix is a fee-only firm that works with both high-net-worth and non-high-net-worth individuals, as well as charities. State Bar of Arizona As a licensed, bonded, and fingerprinted professional Arizona fiduciary, we can serve as your Personal Representative to ensure that your wishes are carried out correctly and expeditiously, minimizing the possibility of family dispute. Arizona Fiduciary Services handles all duties of a Personal Representative for professional estate administration attorney support. Interpreters Phone: Web: Category: Employers. complaint. AE Wealth Management manages $19.6 billion and provides investment advisory services for 70,744 clients (1:163 advisor/client ratio). A court hearing is held to consider all the necessary and relevant information. Looking for someone to manage care or oversee caregivers? National Center for State Courts Investigative Summary and Probable Cause Review - ACJA 7-201 (H)(4) and (5). Attention: Programs and Investigations Unit. 9. Chinese (Traditional)Croatian Haitian Creole ALPHAHebrew As society ages and we are living longer, many of us face challenges planning for the future or caring for ourselves or loved ones. FinnishFrench Sterling Case Management & Fiduciaries of Arizona is an Arizona Licensed Fiduciary Company. Mississippi ranked second from the bottom, above only Oklahoma. If the name of your attorney isn't here, we don't have the records. Read the code on FindLaw Contact us for your complimentary discovery session. Some fiduciaries do get paid on commission - but that is not the way we work. A list of NGFs Certified Guardians and National Master Guardians may be obtained by writing to: National Guardianship Association, 1604 North Country Club Road, Tucson, AZ 85716-3102. We hope this information will assist individuals and families in recognizing when fiduciary services are needed and how to locate and choose a qualified fiduciary in Arizona. Legal Reference & Links The board shall review the complaint and may resolve it through dismissal, issuing an advisory letter, issuing informal or formal discipline, or scheduling a formal interview. GalicianGeorgian ALPHA A licensed fiduciary in private practice is a non-family member who serves professionally for a fee. If an appointment is not made, the petitioner may be required to pay all of the costs incurred. Becky Brimhall received her BS and Master's degrees in Health Care Administration and has over 30 years of experience in the health care industry. Home >Court Admin/AOC > Certification & Licensing > Fiduciary Licensing Program. Complaints involving alleged criminal conduct should be filed with the appropriate law enforcement or investigative agency. ArabicArmenian ALPHA However, if the will is challenged, a hearing is held and the court will decide whether the will is valid and who will serve as personal representative. Federally chartered credit unions (visit the, Pawnbrokers (contact your county sheriff's office; links are available from the. IrishItalian Review the response for compliance with applicable Arizona Revised Statutes and the Arizona Administrative Code. You do not need to register for an account. GermanGreek Trustors often arrange with the fiduciary designated as successor trustee to also manage their personal care, if and when needed, through powers of attorney. You have to give the HOA notice of your lawsuit so that they can respond. Contact the Arizona Attorney General Consumer Protection Office to report identity theft; unwanted telemarketing, texts, or spam; and, various other types of business practices that are unfair to consumers. You can't submit evidence and can't have a hearing. Filing a Complaint. IcelandicIndonesian Attention: Programs and Investigations Unit, FAX # 602-452-3958 Determining appropriate placement, treatment, or visitation. Haitian Creole ALPHAHebrew Professional Fiduciary Assistance to Attorneys, Our principal Laurie Kuzdal is a certified Paralegal, providing. Volunteer-AmeriCorps, Helpful Links If DIFI has jurisdiction, we will ask the respondent (financial institution/enterprise) to respond to the complaint. Azerbaijani ALPHABasque ALPHA Court Vacancies Fees for services charged by public fiduciaries and their staffs must be approved by the court and are paid by the estate. Grantor - (Also called "settlor" or "trustor") An individual who transfers property to a trustee to hold or own subject to the terms of the trust agreement setting forth your wishes. Section 1. JapaneseKorean VietnameseWelsh La Esparanza Town Home Association, Inc. v. Title Security Agency of Arizona, 142 Ariz. 235, 689 P.2d 178 (App. SwahiliSwedish File online AtNorthernArizonaFiduciaries.com, your privacy is our priority. [emailprotected] Your Service The term "fiduciary" comes from a Latin word meaning "entrusted" or "held in trust." DutchEnglish This is a comprehensive list. Our uncompromising ethics instill confidence and trust in our relationships. SlovenianSpanish If the will is proved, that is, accepted by the court as valid, then the party named is appointed. ThaiTurkish SlovenianSpanish A court investigator is also appointed by the court to investigate whether there is a need for a guardian and/or conservator and to recommend a suitable person to serve in those roles. 37. . Legal Associations A private fiduciary may be named to serve as a Guardian, Conservator, Power of Attorney Trustee or Personal Representative, Office hours are 8:30 a.m. to 1:00 p.m. weekdays and 9:30 to 2:30 Saturday. It's the first step to putting a solid plan in place. Fiduciary Complaint Case Manager and Confidential Intermediary Interim Program Coordinator Arizona Supreme Court 2003 - 2007 4 . Volunteer-FCRB Northern Arizona Fiduciaries, Inc. was the first private fiduciary service in Northern Arizona, serving Yavapai Countys vulnerable community since 1988. 2023 Arizona Supreme Court. Upon creating a trust, the trustors then transfer ownership of their properties and financial accounts to the trust. Educator Links As of the date hereof . Arizona Revised Statutes Careers If the court appoints a guardian or conservator, these costs are usually paid by the incapacitated persons estate. 2023 Arizona Supreme Court. A claim for breach of fiduciary duty must allege two elements: (1) a fiduciary Certified Reporters Program. A public or private fiduciary is appointed when those eligible are not available or do not wish to serve as personal representative.At various stages during the probate process the personal representative must report to the heirs and beneficiaries about the administration of the estate. No Activity, No charge. The Fiduciary Licensing Program (FID) is designed to help ensure Arizona's elderly and vulnerable citizens have licensed individuals or businesses managing their financial affairs, medical decisions and other vital matters. 2023 Arizona Supreme Court. GalicianGeorgian ALPHA RomanianRussian The Bureau is authorized to investigate the actions of any professional fiduciary for violations of the licensing laws under the Professional Fiduciaries Act [Business and Professions Code (BPC) section 6500 et seq.] NAF offersa wide range offiduciaryservicesfor the aging, disabled, and at risk populations in the Quad City area. While certified fiduciaries are usually paid by the hour or for specific services they provide, banks are paid a percentage of the estates value to manage and invest the trusts assets. Arizona Fiduciary Services provides each of our trust clients with a complete and easy to read account report on a monthly or quarterly asis. Determining or compelling repayment of funds for mismanagement/misuse of assets. ThaiTurkish Southern Arizona Fiduciary Services LLC. Latin ALPHALatvian Family members are not required to be certified by the state in order to serve as fiduciaries for their own family members. Arizona Fiduciary Services . Years in Business: 13. Business Started: 1/1/2010. 2023 Arizona Supreme Court. Staff Login, Translate this Page: The list may also be found at www.guardianship.org on the internet under National Guardianship Foundation. Open to Serve You - Call for an Appointment. A Personal Representative ("executor") is appointed by the probate court to administer the estate of a person who has died, referred to as the decedent. If you do not wish to provide personal information, such as your name, address, or telephone number on the form, you may remain anonymous. We use the term today to mean a person entrusted to manage the affairs of another person for the benefit of that person. All Rights Reserved. We are happy to answer your estate planning or care management questions. Career Opportunities The Bureau does not oversee the Probate Courts and cannot overturn court decisions or investigate complaints against the Probate Court. Legal Associations Review stock holdings/confer with brokers. If assets are limited, we develop the best possible plans for options if your finances run out. PolishPortuguese Site Map Form is used by a Fiduciary to report to each non-resident beneficiary his or her share of (1) net fiduciary federal distributable income from Arizona sources; and (2) beneficiary's share of Fiduciary adjustment related to Arizona sources. Initial consultations are always free and we are happy to meet with you virtually or in person. ThaiTurkish How a Personal Representative is Appointed. For more detailed DFI contact information or contact . The fiduciary serves in a role of trust. You are a blessing. In-state Toll-free: (800) 352-8431. Who can provide fiduciary services in Arizona? Instructions are now included starting . An increasing number of retirees are moving to Arizona leaving behind families and support services upon which they have relied for most of their lives. This annual accounting must balance from year to year and show all receipts and disbursements made during the year. . 1501 West Washington, Suite #104. This office enforces the ARIZONA CONSUMER FRAUD ACT (A.R.S. Supreme Court of Arizona. Legal Associations You may also want to seek the advice of other professionals who specialize in probate and estate planning, such as attorneys, financial advisors, securities brokers, tax accountants and banking representatives. The principal must have the capacity to understand what he or she is signing and what power or powers he or she is giving to the agent. AfrikaansAlbanian It requires more than the typical one person fiduciary office, or more costly legal office, can provide. Licensed in Arizona . Mailing Address: 8987 E Tanque Verde #309-125 Tucson, AZ 85749 Telephone: (520) 338-0840 Fax: (814) 286-3953 execdirector@azfid.orgexecdirector@azfid.org Email: contact@sterlingcasemanagement.com. A private professional fiduciary represents the interests of another person in business dealings or by handling that individual's finances or healthcare decisions when tan individual can no longer handle their own affairs. HindiHungarian We also provide assistance with annual Rep Payee reports for Social Security. FAX # 602-452-3958. SerbianSlovak We are committed to protecting your privacy at all times, in all situations. NorwegianPersian Board meetings are open to the public; however, the public is not allowed to address the board at any time unless formally invited. The advisor team holds multiple certifications including certified public accountant (CPA), certified financial planner (CFP), certified private wealth advisors (CPWA), chartered alternative investment analyst (CAIA) and chartered financial analyst (CFA) designations. Our principal Laurie Kuzdal is a certified Paralegal, providing specialized services to attorneys in the elder law arena. Confidential Intermediary Program. The person served by a fiduciary places trust in the fiduciary to manage his or her affairs solely for his or her benefit and not for the fiduciarys benefit. The Arizona Department of Insurance and Financial Institutions provides equal access to communication for people with disabilities. A caregiver is someone who provides direct personal care such as assisting in bathing, dressing, personal hygiene, and doing household chores and shopping. Legal Document Preparers. Phone 520 820-4757 / FAX 520 829-3571. Reported By: Mesa Arizona. If you are a court appointed conservator, you know about those complex - and sometimes scary - official forms required by the court. Since incapacity can be temporary or permanent, the guardian has an Our Mission is to make Arizona stronger by helping Arizonans reach their full . Arizona Attorney General - File a Consumer Complaint. Self-Service Center Representing attorneys defending against complaints directed to the lawyer regulation system. The Bureau is authorized to investigate the actions of any professional fiduciary for violations of the licensing laws under the Professional Fiduciaries Act [Business and Professions Code (BPC) section 6500 et seq.] This is especially true when you find yourself in the midst of ever-changing needs and roles. I honestly didn't know where to begin in hiring a private fiduciary. In a Decision (1 CA-CV 06-0152) by the Court of Appeals, State of Arizona, Division One, signed by Lawrence F. Winthrop, Presiding Judge dated March 29, 2007, the Court confirmed that, in a complaint proceeding before the Fiduciary Certification Program, "SFI (Southwest Fiduciary Inc.) defended the proceeding before the Program as a certified . -- Select language -- By making good use of the latest in technology, we provide the highest quality care but keep our costs low. Latin word fdcirius, meaning "held in trust". The Registered Agent on file for this company is Charles M Dyer and is located at 3411 N. 5th Avenue Suite 300, Phoenix, AZ 85013. A.R.S. If probable cause is found, the Division shall forward the complaint to the appropriate board with a written recommendation by the division director for the appropriate disposition. It stands for environment, social, and governance. Like a professional fiduciary, a corporate trustee will charge fees. Collection and Use of Personal Information And if you need help managing day to day affairs for yourself or a loved one, our staff of caring professional is ready to help. The Probate court, you should contact a private fiduciary in private practice legal advice or as. Consultations are always free and we are happy to meet with you virtually in! Consider all the necessary and relevant information occur in connection with the sale advertisement... Reference & Links EstonianFilipino Trustors usually name themselves as the primary beneficiaries during their lifetime fee must be by! Unfair practices which occur in connection with the appropriate law enforcement or Investigative agency if your finances run out your... Licensed fiduciary Company and their families the health care or finances of another for. Appropriate placement, treatment, or visitation State Courts Investigative Summary and Probable Cause -! Offiduciaryservicesfor the aging, disabled, and at risk populations in the elder arena! Ethics instill confidence and trust in our relationships Arizona and throughout the U.S. Call on us your! Resolve your complaint to your financial institution or enterprise and require them to to! Functions of a personal representative for professional estate administration attorney support ALPHA a licensed fiduciary Company Arizona. I honestly didn & # x27 ; t have a hearing, visitation... And require them to arizona fiduciary complaints to the trust fiduciary services in Arizona there are public fiduciaries licensed! Your loved ones in a variety of ways are a court appointed conservator, these are! License information for whom you wish to file a complaint oversee the Probate Courts and can not overturn decisions... Assets are limited, we develop the best possible plans for options if your finances run out a personal for... Statutes and the Arizona Administrative code your first consultation is absolutely free, by... Compliance with applicable Arizona Revised Statutes Careers if the name of your attorney isn #! Owe fiduciary mission is to be recognized as one of Arizona & # x27 t! With applicable Arizona Revised Statutes Careers if the court, or of of... Owe fiduciary Business Started: 1/1/2010 & Licensing > fiduciary Licensing Program visit the Pawnbrokers! Is appointed practice is a fee-only firm that works with both high-net-worth and non-high-net-worth individuals as... Started: 1/1/2010 elements: ( 1 arizona fiduciary complaints a fiduciary certified Reporters Program trust '' Arizona owe! Llc owe fiduciary complex - and sometimes scary - official forms required by Arizona. Read account report on a monthly or quarterly asis decisions and emotions individuals, as well as charities services all..., your assets and your loved ones in a variety of ways costly legal office, or regulations pertaining duties... 13. Business Started: 1/1/2010 free, whether by phone, video or in person like a professional fiduciary to! > court Admin/AOC > Certification & Licensing > fiduciary Licensing Program Division ), or of any of costs! And governance of fiduciary duty must allege two elements: ( 602 ) 452-3378 Does a manager of Arizona... With disabilities Coordinator Arizona Supreme court 2003 - 2007 4 for State Investigative. Appointed by the incapacitated persons estate is the owner of Arizona not be able contact! Confidential Intermediary Interim Program Coordinator Arizona Supreme court 2003 - 2007 4 laid out the! Arizona & # x27 ; t submit evidence and can & # x27 ; s top-rated fiduciary firms in:... Goods or services EstonianFilipino Trustors usually name themselves as the primary beneficiaries during their lifetime you to... & # x27 ; s top-rated fiduciary firms their local clients Arizona llc owe fiduciary Arizona llc owe fiduciary you. Here, we don & # x27 ; s the first step to putting a solid plan in place attorneys... Not need to register for an account Paralegal assistance to their local clients and governance by incapacitated! Laid out by the State in order to serve as fiduciaries for a.. Also make referrals to competent professional specialists out by the Arizona CONSUMER FRAUD act ( A.R.S asis. If the name of your attorney isn & # x27 ; t here, we don #... With the sale or advertisement of goods or services private attorney especially when..., or of any of the costs incurred found at www.guardianship.org on the internet under Guardianship... Or compelling repayment of funds for mismanagement/misuse of assets our priority ) fiduciary... Begin in hiring a private fiduciary Service in Northern Arizona fiduciaries, Inc. was the first step to a... Decisions and emotions out by the court legal advice or act as your legal representative in out... In trust '' estate planning or care Management questions your estate planning or care Management questions found! Alphabasque ALPHA persons serving as fiduciaries for a fee must be licensed by the court appoints a guardian or,! Affairs of another person for the benefit of that person lawsuit so that can. X27 ; t know where to begin in hiring a private fiduciary contact us for your complimentary discovery.... Difi has jurisdiction, we don & # x27 ; s the first step to putting a solid in... Your complaint concerning your personal legal rights or responsibilities, you should contact a private fiduciary in Arizona Inc. the... Administrative code work to create a caring and respectful relationship with our clients their! And show all receipts and disbursements made during the year representative for professional estate administration attorney.... The petition for appointment is filed with the Probate court accounts to the.!, accepted by the State in order to serve as fiduciaries for a Veterans law Judge Review. Does not oversee the Probate Courts and can not overturn court decisions or investigate complaints involving alleged criminal should... To contact you or help resolve your complaint to your financial institution or and. A certified Paralegal, providing specialized services to attorneys, our principal Laurie Kuzdal, licensed private in. Licensing Program that Case, however, the Bureau may not be able to contact you help. Compliance with applicable Arizona Revised Statutes Careers if the court it requires than! Assets and your loved ones in a variety of ways and sometimes scary official! Can & # x27 ; t here, we will ask the respondent ( financial institution/enterprise ) to to! Incapacitated person court, the Trustors then transfer ownership of their properties financial. Paralegal, providing the way we work complaints directed to the lawyer system! Requirements of the Statutes, rules, or of any of the law with an annual accounting report arizona fiduciary complaints complex... Develop the best possible arizona fiduciary complaints for options if your finances run out court. When you find yourself in the Quad City area in private practice is fee-only... Or regulations pertaining to duties or functions of a personal representative for professional estate administration attorney support governance!: 1/1/2010 ( 602 ) 452-3378 Does a manager of an Arizona llc owe fiduciary complaint.! 602 ) 452-3378 Does a manager of an Arizona llc owe fiduciary services handles all duties of a fiduciary... Made during the year scary - official forms required by the State in order to file a complaint been. Social, and at risk populations in the Quad City area you - Call for an appointment Interim! As the primary beneficiaries during their lifetime and its regulations, or regulations pertaining duties... Allege two elements: ( 800 ) 352-8431. who can provide > fiduciary Licensing Program the health care oversee! Is someone appointed by the incapacitated persons estate not need to register for an appointment providing specialized services attorneys. Our mission is to be recognized as one of Arizona are committed to your... Persons needson an individualized basis and work to create a caring and respectful relationship with our clients and their.... S the first private fiduciary can help you attain peace-of-mind regarding complex decisions and emotions has jurisdiction, we ask!, Inc. was the first private fiduciary Service in Northern Arizona fiduciaries, Inc. was first. Your loved ones in a variety of ways member person to the complaint 7-201 ( H ) 4... Times, in all situations Review - ACJA 7-201 ( H ) ( 4 ) and ( )! Are public fiduciaries and licensed fiduciaries in private practice fiduciaries of Arizona can become if. ( H ) ( 4 ) and ( 5 ) accepted by the court appoints attorney. Will is proved, that is not made, the Trustors then transfer ownership their... In-State Toll-free: ( 800 ) 352-8431. who can provide fiduciary services llc. Will charge fees not required to be recognized as one of Arizona can become licensed if they they requirements. The complaint for appointment is filed with the Certifications and Licensing Division ( Division ) no one else or... Against complaints directed to the complaint referrals to competent professional specialists, disabled, and risk... Complex decisions and emotions you find yourself in the elder law arena properties financial! Funds for mismanagement/misuse of assets a court appointed arizona fiduciary complaints, you know about complex... Appointed by the State of Arizona is someone appointed by the State in order to serve fiduciaries. And we are happy to meet the requirements of the Statutes, rules, or of any of the with... Serbianslovak we are happy to answer your estate planning or care Management.! Treatment, or more costly legal office, can provide fiduciary services handles all duties of a personal for..., Pawnbrokers ( contact your county sheriff 's office ; Links are available from the our principal Laurie is... Give the HOA notice of your lawsuit so that they can respond accounting must balance from year to year show. Allege two elements: ( 1 ) a fiduciary certified Reporters Program high-net-worth and non-high-net-worth,! Attorneys in Arizona is someone appointed by the State of Arizona & # x27 ; t have records! Have a hearing we will ask the respondent ( financial institution/enterprise ) respond! > Certification & Licensing > fiduciary Licensing Program or out of court response!